8. července 2006
Byl Theodor Herzl antisemita?
Antisemita je ten, kdo nenávidí Židy. Self-hating Jew je Žid, který nenávidí židovství v sobě. Rozdíl mezi antisemitou a self-hating Jew je tak pouze v národnosti subjektu. Albert S. Lindemann napsal: "Herzl himself came close to the position of blaming the victim; at least insofar as he considered the defects of Jews in Europe to be the most fundamental reason that they were hated by non-Jews. Herzl is not an easy man to pin down, but a number of scholars have arrived at the paradoxical conclusion that this founder of modern Zionism might be considered a "self-hating Jew." His admiration of the Gentile world -- his fondest dream was to be reborn as a Prussian Junker -- was remarkable, whereas his comments in his diary about many of the Jews he met and worked with were often caustic, even cruel and ugly. No less remarkable was Herzl's apparent lack of hatred for Gentiles, even the anti-Semites among them. The Jewish state he hoped to create was to be liberal-democratic, having few if any connections with Jewish tradition (about which, at any rate, he was not particularly well informed). Again, in a book so massively detailed and one in which Herzl might be described as the hero, Vital devotes curiously little attention to these glaring paradoxes and mostly ignores the recent secondary works that have brought them up."
Přihlásit se k odběru:
Komentáře k příspěvku (Atom)
To je opravdu kuriosní! Ono i dnes největší fanatiky sionismu najdete mezi judeofilními góji, ale že byl Herzl až tak kritický a obdivoval Prušáky, to je pro mě novinka. Bylo-li takových mezi Židy víc, nelze se divit, že vznikl Mein Kampf.
OdpovědětVymazat